Silence on Russia’s Hospital Bombing in Ukraine vs. Outrage Over Gaza
Ukrainian army medics attend to a wounded soldier hit by a FPV drone at a stabilization point as the war between Russia and Ukraine continues, in the direction of Pokrovsk frontline, Donetsk Oblast, Ukraine, July 17, 2024. (Pablo Miranzo/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Silence on Russia’s Hospital Bombing in Ukraine vs. Outrage Over Gaza

Experts accused Russia of funding pro-Palestinian protests and using the pro-Palestinian cause to promote its own agenda

Last week, the Okhmatdyt Children’s Hospital in Ukraine was targeted by a Russian missile attack. The children’s hospital, which is Ukraine’s largest, sustained significant damage, and two people were killed. The attack was just one element of a deadly Russian strike that killed at least 38 and injured more than 100.

Despite the devastating nature of the hospital attack, the international public reaction was relatively muted. Social media campaigns against Russian aggression in Ukraine, such as #StandWithUkraine and #StopRussianAggression, have seen widespread engagement, but no specific campaign was created to address the children’s hospital attack.

This muted response stands in stark contrast to online activism regarding the Israel-Hamas war. In May, an AI-generated image of tents arranged to spell “All Eyes on Rafah” went viral, with over 44 million shares on Instagram and nearly 28 million on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter. The post was inspired by the Israeli military’s action in the southern Gazan city of Rafah, where hundreds of thousands of Palestinian civilians were then sheltering.

Throughout the past 10 months of war between Israel and Gaza, 10.7 million posts have been made on Instagram with the hashtag #FreePalestine. In comparison, only 1.9 million posts were made with the hashtag #StandWithUkraine during the two years of war in Ukraine.

Ukrainian media expert and political analyst Alexey Kovzhun explained that contrast by noting that the public has gotten used to images of Ukrainian suffering.

Ukraine is gradually being perceived by our allies similarly to Syria. People are getting used to it: ‘Ukraine was shelled by rockets. Another Russian atrocity, nothing special.

“Ukraine is gradually being perceived by our allies similarly to Syria,” he told The Media Line. “People are getting used to it: ‘Ukraine was shelled by rockets. Another Russian atrocity, nothing special.’”

He said that the decreasing public outrage over Russian war crimes is a predictable phenomenon.

“It’s human nature. As we know, the death of one person is a tragedy, but the death of a million is a statistic,” he said.

Kovzhun also accused Russia of funding and training Hamas members and funding pro-Palestinian protests.

“When we see such a coordinated chorus, flags of the same size, and professionally printed posters, we understand that this is a simulation of an organic, natural protest. And I am deeply convinced that behind these European, American, and ostensibly pro-Palestinian demonstrations are Russian funds,” he said.

According to political scientist Leonid Goldenberg, the different narratives regarding Gaza and Ukraine can be traced back to the Cold War. Leftists understand Ukraine and Israel both to be “proxies of American hegemony,” he told The Media Line.

The Russian narrative paints the West as hypocritical for allowing Israel to bomb Gaza but sanctioning Russia for merely “saving its own people,” he said, noting that discourse of this sort “fits well into the left’s anticolonial agenda.”

The Western audience learned about Ukraine only recently, unlike the well-known Israeli-Palestinian conflict. When the war in Israel occurred, Russia, along with its allies—primarily China, Iran, and Qatar—began using already established anti-Israel narratives.

“Dislike for Israel in this narrative has existed for many years,” Goldenberg continued. “The Western audience learned about Ukraine only recently, unlike the well-known Israeli-Palestinian conflict. When the war in Israel occurred, Russia, along with its allies—primarily China, Iran, and Qatar—began using already established anti-Israel narratives.”

Russian historian Maxim Kuzakhmetov also described a double standard between responses to the war in Ukraine and the war in Gaza. He condemned the international indifference toward the hostages still held in Gaza and criticized the structure of the UN, which allows Russia a permanent seat on the Security Council.

After the fall of the Soviet Union, which had been actively involved in the UN’s establishment, Russia took over the Soviet Union’s role in the organization.

“It was an utterly insane decision to transfer all the powers of the Soviet Union to Russia,” Kuzakhmetov told The Media Line. “It’s absurd. All 15 former Soviet republics should have had to join the UN anew, but Russia became the successor state, and this legacy, this sad history, continues to this day.”

The EU called for accountability for Russian war crimes and stressed the need for enhanced air defense for Ukraine. However, no special actions have been taken against Russia, which, despite its crimes, still remains a UN member with veto power.

Because of Russia’s veto power, the UN has little influence, he explained.

Russia is an obvious terrorist state that befriends Iran, Hamas, the Taliban, and North Korea. In contrast, the helpless Western world is still trying to negotiate with someone while Ukrainians are paying the price.

“Russia is an obvious terrorist state that befriends Iran, Hamas, the Taliban, and North Korea,” Kuzakhmetov said. “In contrast, the helpless Western world is still trying to negotiate with someone while Ukrainians are paying the price.”

“It’s wild that a Russian representative sits in the UN, says whatever he wants, and they listen to him, translate it into different languages to maintain dialogue,” Kuzakhmetov shared with The Media Line. “It’s as if Nazi Germany had not been excluded from the League of Nations. Imagine, in 1942, with concentration camps, hundreds of thousands of Jews being exterminated, and a German representative telling something at the League of Nations. That simply could not have happened.”

Kovzhun also criticized the UN for its decision to meet with the Taliban even after Taliban representatives demanded that no Afghan women be allowed to participate in the meeting.

Goldenberg highlighted that some UN structures have been implicated in financing terrorism and that the organization often assesses humanitarian crises with a clear bias. He referenced the well-known incident of the Gaza famine, where the UN only accounted for humanitarian aid that passed through its channels, ignoring for over eight months the transparent data provided by Israel.

“When the majority of countries in the UN are neither democratic nor liberal but have the same voting rights as everyone else, how can we protect the integrity of democracy and liberalism?” he asked.

Kovzhun also highlighted other areas where Russia is leaving its marks.

“Another front where Russia is committing atrocities is Syria, and no one is paying attention,” he pointed out.

Since September 2015, Russia has conducted a significant military intervention in Syria to support the government of President Bashar al-Assad. The intervention’s goals included combating terrorist groups such as ISIS and al-Nusra Front, stabilizing the Assad regime, and securing Russian strategic interests in the region. The conflict has led to the displacement of millions of Syrians, exacerbated by continued fighting and destruction of infrastructure, complicating humanitarian efforts. According to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, Russian airstrikes have killed over 8,700 civilians.

Kovzhun explained that the global public is repeating a past scenario without recognizing the connections between wars.

“The world is making the same mistake as in the first half of the last century when people who should have recognized patterns failed to see the bigger picture of a world war. This is precisely what is happening now in the West. In my deep conviction, without Russia’s support and without training Hamas militants in modern warfare methods, including military operations, there would be no war in Israel.”

TheMediaLine
WHAT WOULD YOU GIVE TO CHANGE THE MISINFORMATION
about the
ISRAEL-HAMAS WAR?
Personalize Your News
Upgrade your experience by choosing the categories that matter most to you.
Click on the icon to add the category to your Personalize news
Browse Categories and Topics