Time After Time, Netanyahu’s Opposition Fails
Netanyahu faces criticism amid the hostage crisis, as well as alleged personal motives. However, the opposition remains fragmented, leaving his power secure
Tens of thousands of Israelis are protesting the government in Jerusalem on Thursday, a day after they marched to the capital and amassed in the city, blocking traffic for hours.
The protesters are demonstrating against the resumption of Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza, coinciding with the termination of the head of Israel’s secret service, Ronen Bar. Explaining his decision, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he had lost confidence in Bar.
Earlier this week, Israeli fighter jets began to pound Gaza several weeks after Netanyahu vowed that if Hamas does not accept American ceasefire proposals, he would order the army to reignite the war effort against the terrorist organization.
In response to both developments, demonstrators took to the streets, venting their frustrations.
This is a very vocal protest which is characterized by the participation of former high-ranking security officials from the army and police. It is also happening during a war, with the hostage crisis in the background, making it not just a protest against Netanyahu, but a protest to get the hostages out.
“This is a very vocal protest which is characterized by the participation of former high-ranking security officials from the army and police,” Dr. Yonatan Freeman, an international relations expert at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, told The Media Line. “It is also happening during a war, with the hostage crisis in the background, making it not just a protest against Netanyahu, but a protest to get the hostages out.”
After years of protests against Netanyahu, it is hard to see what will make this one different, despite the presence of former senior figures in the defense and political establishment. In other words, the chances of this protest fulfilling the wish of its participants to remove Netanyahu from office are slim.
It’s doomed to fail. People are obsessed with Netanyahu, and all of this is delusional. There are no values or ideology behind the protests; they have nothing to sell. Being against Netanyahu is not a value.
“It’s doomed to fail,” said Dina Dayan, a social activist and member of the Labor Party. “People are obsessed with Netanyahu, and all of this is delusional. There are no values or ideology behind the protests; they have nothing to sell. Being against Netanyahu is not a value.”
Fifty-nine out of 255 hostages that Hamas took in its surprise offensive carried out against Israel on October 7th, 2023, remain in Gaza. At least 35 of them are presumed dead. American proposals brought forward by Steve Witkoff, the American Special Envoy to the Middle East, which were aimed at extending the ceasefire that ended last month and bringing to a release of more hostages, have been accepted by Israel and shot down by Hamas.
Hamas’ attack stunned Israel and shed light on years of Hamas’ empowerment enabled by the Jewish state. Netanyahu, a veteran at the helm, was viewed by many in the Israeli public as responsible for the situation. In addition, the senior military command failed to foresee the attack and respond swiftly to mitigate its scope. His approval ratings plummeted in the immediate aftermath of the war, and his opponents were quick to write him off, believing his era was over.
But the war elongated and evolved, quickly incorporating other fronts as Israel faced enemies near and far. Netanyahu, a political maverick, began recovering, taking credit for successes and brushing off demands for a national inquiry commission, claiming the time for investigation was only after the war effort concluded.
This holiday season, give to:
Truth and understanding
The Media Line's intrepid correspondents are in Israel, Gaza, Lebanon, Syria and Pakistan providing first-person reporting.
They all said they cover it.
We see it.
We report with just one agenda: the truth.
Netanyahu is still pretty strong at the polls, and the base for his power continues to be solid. One of the main factors behind this is the lack of unity amongst the opposition. They cannot agree as to what needs to be done about the various issues.
“Netanyahu is still pretty strong at the polls, and the base for his power continues to be solid,” Freeman said. “One of the main factors behind this is the lack of unity amongst the opposition. They cannot agree as to what needs to be done about the various issues.”
At 75, Netanyahu is a veteran figure on the political scene. Many Israelis have only a distant memory of politics without his presence. Throughout the years, no real alternative has emerged, neither from within his bloc nor from the opposition.
“On the personal level, he is far more charismatic than others,” Dr. Moti Gigi, a senior lecturer in the Sociology and Communications Department at the Sapir Academic College, told The Media Line. “Ideologically, what is the left offering? There is an ideological vacuum in the left bloc in Israel, in line with the global trend in other western democracies.”
The current protest movement is an impromptu coalition between hostage families and the opposition to Netanyahu, which has staged massive protests in recent years for alternating reasons. The Israeli leader has always been a contentious figure, but controversy further engulfed him in 2016 when the Israel Police began investigating him on suspicions of corruption, breach of trust, accepting bribes, and fraud. Netanyahu was indicted in 2019, and his trial began a year later. All the while, he has denied any wrongdoing, claiming he is being targeted for political reasons.
Israeli law allows a prime minister to remain in office while under trial.
A sitting prime minister under trial creates doubts about his motives. This creates a tricky twilight zone which is dangerous to Israel’s already fragile democracy
“A sitting prime minister under trial creates doubts about his motives,” said Gigi. “This creates a tricky twilight zone which is dangerous to Israel’s already fragile democracy.”
Major protests against Netanyahu began during the COVID pandemic when the longest-serving Israeli premier was accused of infringing on privacy rights, mismanaging the financial fallout of the crisis, and easily imposing lockdowns in addition to enforcing a strict vaccination regime. The protest movement then evolved to focus on Netanyahu’s trial. Netanyahu has served six terms in office. Between 1996 and the present day, barring two non-consecutive terms, Netanyahu has led different coalitions. The current one, sworn in in late 2022, is considered the most far-right and brought forward a highly controversial proposal to reform the judiciary. The reform, which opponents called a coup, was meant to curb the influence of the judiciary and remove restraints from the government. This plunged the country into yet another round of protests that was abruptly brought to a halt by Hamas’ brutal attack.
The war has been going on for 17 months and has become Israel’s longest war. The brief lull in the demonstrations ended as frustration from the lengthy fighting, the increased burden on the reservist soldiers, the hostage crisis, and the government’s refusal to establish an inquiry committee into what led to Hamas’ attack led people to the streets again.
Still, Netanyahu’s approval ratings began to recuperate.
“The parties in power are not paying a high electoral price due to the protests,” Dr. Or Tuttnauer, an expert on opposition parties from MZES, the University of Mannheim, told The Media Line. “The Likud maintains around 20% of public support consistently and the coalition partners represent ideological groups who see the government as a tool to realize their ambitions. With this in mind, the demonstrations only encourage them to avoid any possibility of moving the elections forward, with the hopes that whatever price they are paying, the electoral damage will diminish.”
The parliamentary opposition to Netanyahu is highly fragmented. It includes far-left elements, Arab parties, and far-right elements. At its center are two parties that define themselves as centrists but have right-wing political and security views that make their distinction from Netanyahu’s Likud vague at best.
The fact that the opposition has no clear message or one single leader weakens its ability to succeed. Netanyahu still has a mandate to execute his policies.
“The fact that the opposition has no clear message or one single leader weakens its ability to succeed,” Freeman said. “Netanyahu still has a mandate to execute his policies.”
Reeling after Hamas’ attack, Israelis took a further turn to the right in what was already a clear slant of the public in recent decades.
“Most of the people are in the center, or perhaps even in the right,” said Tuttnauer. “So, in order to get more mandates, they have to talk like the government. But when faced with the choice of who to vote for and the options are similar, voters usually choose what is more authentic or for the party that is already in power.”
The Likud party has maintained a steady lead in the polls in recent months, with the Netanyahu bloc projected to withhold its majority consistently if elections were held today. Netanyahu’s push to dismiss Bar, the head of the Shin Bet security agency and also the Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara, has his opposition alleging he is trying to remove gatekeepers from their position and harm Israeli democracy. The opposition believes Bar’s involvement in investigations into recent allegations of corruption by aides in Netanyahu’s office is what led to Netanyahu’s decision to sack him, while the Israeli premier claims he has long lost trust in the senior defense official, who himself has taken responsibility for the organization’s failure to thwart Hamas’ surprise offensive.
“This offensive has been planned for weeks,” said Freeman. “If it was a political move, Bar would not have participated and resigned.”
On Thursday evening, the Israeli cabinet is expected to meet and approve Bar’s dismissal. The Shin Bet has played a critical role during the war on Hamas in Gaza. Bar appeared in a video released by the Israeli military; he is seen alongside the army chief-of-staff overseeing airstrikes on the Gaza Strip. He was instrumental in approving the plans to resume the war on Hamas.
Netanyahu’s opponents accuse him of prolonging the war and endangering the hostages to delay his trial and secure his political future. They frame every decision by Netanyahu as personally motivated to ensure his political survival and evade a guilty verdict in court. The premier’s senior coalition partners threatened that if he did not resume the war effort, they would resign from the government, essentially toppling it and plunging the country into an election.
“If the war expands, this would be in favor of Netanyahu and give him more support due to an unstable security situation,” said Freeman. “If indeed the war will pressure Hamas into agreeing to release hostages and bring to a ceasefire, as Netanyahu promises, this will also weaken the opposition. As long as the opposition is fragmented, the public has no message to rally around.”
Early Thursday, the Israeli parliament approved the framework for the 2025 budget. The vote removed a key hurdle to the budget approval, granting Netanyahu quiet on the political front. The next election is scheduled for is slated for October 2026.
I have no doubt that the right-wing will win this election. The opposition is offering no product and no vision that will end this. Netanyahu is under no political threat.
“I have no doubt that the right-wing will win this election,” Dayan told The Media Line. “The opposition is offering no product and no vision that will end this.”
“Netanyahu is under no political threat,” she concluded.
